Saturday, January 21, 2006

Girls Will Be Girls...and That Sometimes Means Cruel


Blogroll Me!

I've blogged before about watching girls behave like their mothers-- catty, snooty, cliqueish. But those were little girls I was talking about. Seven-year-old girls who behave that way from kindergarten onwards, as I've witnessed.

Today I saw grade 8 girls in action. There was a girls' shabbaton being hosted at my shul for seudat shlishit. These were girls from my children's school, so I've seen some of them over the years I've been affiliated with the school, watched them grow up in the past 6 years.

True, some of these 13 and 14 year olds look like my eight-year-old daughter, ie. that petite, small in body and just little-girl-like. Others look like well-developed young women of 17 or 18 with a flare for fashion and hairstyles.

I watched how they grouped together, most of them in threes and fours, as they sat in shul for mincha and maariv. Yet there was one lone girl, intent on her davening, and pretending, I'm sure, to ignore the fact that nobody was sitting with her. I HURT FOR THIS GIRL. I HURT BADLY FOR THIS GIRL.

I know she is one of the very bright ones in the school, and yes, her brains will carry her far in life. But socialization is rather important, too, and it's hard to have one without the other.

It was so clear to me who were the nice kids in this group, who were the snooty kids in this group and who were the hot-cold kids in this group. And then it was so clear to me who was the ostracized ONE in this group.

I had flashbacks to my school years, to the bright kid, quiet kid, friendly kid, who was a loner, and not necessarily by choice. To the kid who sometimes was afraid to raise her hand in class and answer because then she might be taunted as "teacher's pet" or "browner".

But that same kid was made stronger in a way because of her "position" in the school's totem pole, somewhere at the bottom. And that same former kid is proud that her daughter is sociable and happy and well-liked. Yet that former kid makes it a point to teach said daughter that those attributes are not enough; foremost, she must be NICE...to everyone.

I hope that in 5 years, G-d willing, when my daughter is in grade 8 at a shabbaton, there will be mothers looking around the room of girls and assessing this assembly of females. They will notice my daughter in the group, will think to themselves, "She looks like a nice girl" and many of them will be able to add, "Not only does she look like a nice girl, I know she is a nice girl!"

Such is a mother's wish.

7 comments:

cruisin-mom said...

I wish for you to get your wish, Pearl

tuesdaywishes said...

If it was my kid who was sitting alone, she does that on purpose. She is such a 'frummie'about not talking in shul! The rest of the time, she does have a nice group of friends, I promise.

Rebecca said...

it is so hard to be a little girl but it is probably even harder to be a parent of a little girl and watch these things happen and be absolutely helpless!

torontopearl said...

CM, thank you for your good wishes.

TuesdayWishes, I'm awfully glad to hear that!

Rebecca, what's sad is that the girls start so young; I truly witnessed it when my daughter was just in kindergarten.

Don't worry, Estee, will learn about peer pressure in time...

Tzipster91 said...

I'm with Tuesday on this one. Rocky is really frum about stuff like that, especially since the time the we heard a visiting rabbi speak at the Hashkama minyan about not talkingin shul. Ok, yes, I'm frum about it too. Anyway, she has friends, don't worry. And most of them don't talk in shul either. Hmm...I wonder where Stef (one of her friends, also frum about that type of thing) was?
But you're right about girls. My class was a bunch of absolute cats in gr.7&8, but this year we're a lot less cliquey, and it's a lot better.

Tzipster91 said...

also: been there, done that, glad it happened because of the experience it gave me, wouldn't want to repeat it or make anyone else go through it.

torontopearl said...

tzipster91--Thanks for commenting. Did your mom direct you to my blog?!
Steph, and I guess I know about whom you speak, gave the d'var torah at seudat shlishit. Most of the girls came late to shul; your sis was one of the early ones.
And yes, I see how Steph is a fervent davener, too.